
When I first viewed the early episodes, my reactions were polar - on the one hand, a recognition, a sense of relief that finally people can laugh. On the other, I felt the deep melancholy portrayed occassionally by the talented Laura Linny. As I watch her from week to week, I see her brilliance as an actress in the darker scenes - her expressions, the coming to terms with 'not enough time.'
By making her an upper middle class white lady who doesn't have to worry about co pays or other costs, the authors free her from the tragic drama of cancer for so many people. This also gives her the freedom to carry out her 'bucket list' in ways most of us cannot. Actually, among my favorite scenes so far was the couch burning - it was such a visceral reaction! I have seriously been thinking about which piece of furniture I want to burn...
As the show continues, Cathy's life gets crazier and crazier: she kicks her husband of 20 years out, takes on a sexy lover, lives more and more over the edge. I continue to watch with a kind of horror/ fascination: where are they taking this, and why? Also, her life as a teacher, ostensibly in summer school this season, is totally out of whack: the school seems to have absolutely NO oversite of what goes on in the classroom! (High school teachers - is that possible??)
The producers say they are planning for six seasons - 18 months in real time, covering one season a season (summer, fall, winter, etc.) The producer says "we are keeping up with progress in the field such as clinical trials" - but her diagnosis continues to be terminal. As is the diagnosis for us all, it's just that most of us don't have a date.
Barbara Ehrenreich, who has written eloquently and sharply about the over-cuteness of the breast cancer 'pink' tide also feels the authors err on the side of silly. I tend to agree, but have some kind of perverse enjoyment as I share both the hilarity and the shadows. Like everything tasty, it needs a grain of salt. xSal